Quick answer: To prove duty of care in negligence, start with the neighbour principle from Donoghue v Stevenson (1932), then apply the Caparo test: harm must be reasonably foreseeable, there must be proximity between the parties, and it must be fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty. Policy arguments, such as the floodgates concern, can limit the duty.
Duty of care is the first element of negligence and a core part of Paper 4 (Law of Tort). It appears in problem questions, where you must decide whether the defendant owed the claimant a duty, and in essays on how the test has developed.
The Neighbour Principle
In Donoghue v Stevenson (1932), a woman found a decomposed snail in a bottle of ginger beer bought for her by a friend. The House of Lords held the manufacturer owed her a duty. Lord Atkin said you must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions you can reasonably foresee would injure your neighbour, meaning people so closely and directly affected that you ought to have them in mind.
How the Test Developed
| Case | What it decided |
|---|---|
| Anns v Merton LBC (1978) | Two-stage test: proximity and foreseeability, then any policy reasons to limit the duty. Widely criticised as too broad. |
| Murphy v Brentwood DC (1991) | The House of Lords departed from Anns and favoured incremental development of the law. |
| Caparo Industries v Dickman (1990) | Set out the three-part test below. Auditors did not owe a duty to individual investors who relied on company accounts. |
| Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire (2018) | The Supreme Court said Caparo is not a test to apply to every new case. Courts should follow established categories and develop the law incrementally. |
The Caparo Three-Part Test
- Foreseeability of harm – could a reasonable person foresee harm to this type of claimant? See Bourhill v Young (1943), where a bystander who heard a crash was not within the foreseeable range of harm.
- Proximity – is there a sufficiently close relationship, in time, space or reliance, between the parties?
- Fair, just and reasonable – would it be fair, just and reasonable for the law to impose a duty?
Policy Considerations
Policy is the reason courts sometimes refuse a duty even when harm was foreseeable.
- Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire (1989) – no duty to an individual victim of a serial killer, partly because of concerns about defensive policing.
- Michael v Chief Constable of South Wales Police (2015) – no general duty to protect individuals from harm caused by third parties.
- Other policy concerns include the floodgates argument, the effect on insurance and the wish to avoid indeterminate liability.
Evaluation Points
- The incremental approach in Robinson brings more certainty, but may slow the law’s growth in new situations.
- The “fair, just and reasonable” limb is flexible, but critics say it is vague and gives judges wide discretion.
Applying It to a Problem Question
- Is the situation an established duty category (for example doctor and patient, or road user and road user)? If yes, say so and move on.
- If it is new, apply foreseeability, proximity and fair, just and reasonable.
- Mention relevant policy and reach a conclusion.
Next, see our negligence overview, the topic on causation and remoteness and the guide to psychiatric injury, where special control mechanisms apply.
Free Past Papers and Notes – Download Now
Lock this topic in by practising real Cambridge questions and revising with our free notes:
→ Download Free A Level Law Past Papers & Mark Schemes
→ Free A Level Law Notes (PDF)
→ Free A Level Law Paper 4 Notes: Law of Tort
Check where this topic sits in the official Cambridge International AS & A Level Law 9084 syllabus.
About Sir Owais Mirchawala’s A Level Law Classes
Sir Owais Mirchawala teaches Cambridge International AS & A Level Law (9084) to students across Pakistan and the Gulf. His A2 Level Law course covers Papers 3 and 4 topic by topic through recorded lectures you can study at your own pace, with topical past paper practice, class notes, WhatsApp query support, and homework and mock exam marking. Learn more about Sir Owais Mirchawala, explore the A2 Level Law course, read the A Level Law course FAQs, or message him on WhatsApp to enrol.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Caparo test?
Three questions: was harm reasonably foreseeable, is there proximity between the parties, and is it fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty of care.
Does Caparo apply to every duty of care case?
No. After Robinson (2018), courts first look for an established category of duty and use the Caparo factors mainly for novel situations.
Who was the claimant in Donoghue v Stevenson?
Mrs Donoghue, who became ill after drinking ginger beer that contained a decomposed snail. The manufacturer was held to owe her a duty of care.
Which paper covers duty of care?
Paper 4 (Law of Tort) at A2 Level, under the tort of negligence.
Final Thought
Learn the three limbs, remember one case for each, and always finish with a policy point. That combination earns marks across AO1, AO2 and AO3.
