Quick answer: The Cambridge 9084 syllabus expects you to know the main legal systems of the world: civil law (codified), common law (judge-made precedent), customary law, religious law and mixed systems. You also compare adversarial trials, where the parties lead the case, with inquisitorial trials, where the judge investigates.
This is the first topic in Paper 1 (English Legal System) under “English legal system and its context”. It is often tested as a short answer question and can also appear inside an essay, so you need clear definitions, one example of each system and two or three evaluation points.
The Main Types of Legal System
| System | Main source of law | Typical example |
|---|---|---|
| Common law | Judicial precedent built up case by case, alongside statute | England and Wales, the USA |
| Civil law | A comprehensive written code that judges apply | France, Germany |
| Customary law | Long-standing community practice and tradition | Some indigenous and village communities |
| Religious law | Religious texts and scholarly interpretation | Sharia in some states; canon law in the Catholic Church |
| Mixed system | A blend of two or more of the above | South Africa, Scotland, Pakistan |
Pakistan is a useful example for students here. It inherited the common law tradition from British rule, while Islamic law also shapes parts of the legal framework, for example through the Federal Shariat Court. That makes it a good illustration of a mixed system.
Common Law vs Civil Law
- Common law relies on precedent (stare decisis), so the law develops through judges deciding cases. Strength: flexible and able to adapt. Weakness: can be uncertain and hard to find across many reports.
- Civil law relies on a codified set of rules, such as the French Civil Code. Strength: clear, accessible and predictable. Weakness: can be rigid when new situations arise.
Adversarial vs Inquisitorial Systems
| Feature | Adversarial | Inquisitorial |
|---|---|---|
| Role of the judge | Neutral referee who decides the outcome | Active investigator who questions witnesses and gathers evidence |
| Who presents the evidence? | The two opposing parties | Largely the court, using an investigation file |
| Where used? | England and Wales, USA | France, Germany |
Evaluation points
- Adversarial – for: each side gets to challenge the other’s evidence, and the judge stays impartial. Against: outcomes can depend on the skill and wealth of the lawyers, and it can be slow and costly.
- Inquisitorial – for: aims to find the truth and may reduce the advantage of wealth. Against: places a lot of power in the judge and may risk the judge forming a view early.
Other Ideas in This Topic
Under the same syllabus heading you also study the rule of law, the difference between civil and criminal law, the relationship between law and morality, law and justice, and the importance of fault. For a wider overview, read our English Legal System guide.
Exam Technique
- Define the term in one sentence.
- Give a clear example (country or legal system).
- Add a point of evaluation for AO3 when the question asks you to assess or compare.
Free Past Papers and Notes – Download Now
Lock this topic in by practising real Cambridge questions and revising with our free notes:
→ Download Free A Level Law Past Papers & Mark Schemes
→ Free A Level Law Notes (PDF)
→ Free A Level Law Paper 1 Notes: English Legal System
Check where this topic sits in the official Cambridge International AS & A Level Law 9084 syllabus.
About Sir Owais Mirchawala’s A Level Law Classes
Sir Owais Mirchawala teaches Cambridge International AS & A Level Law (9084) to students across Pakistan and the Gulf. His AS Level Law course covers Papers 1 and 2 topic by topic through recorded lectures you can study at your own pace, with topical past paper practice, class notes, WhatsApp query support, and homework and mock exam marking. Learn more about Sir Owais Mirchawala, explore the AS Level Law course, read the A Level Law course FAQs, or message him on WhatsApp to enrol.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between common law and civil law?
Common law develops mainly through judicial precedent in decided cases, while civil law is based on a comprehensive written code that judges apply.
Is England’s system adversarial or inquisitorial?
England and Wales uses an adversarial system, where the parties present their cases and the judge or jury decides.
Which paper covers legal systems of the world?
Paper 1 (English Legal System) at AS Level, under the topic "English legal system and its context".
Is there an O Level Law syllabus for this topic?
No. Cambridge offers Law only at AS & A Level (9084). There is no O Level or IGCSE Law syllabus.
Final Thought
Learn each system with one example and one strength and weakness. That simple structure is enough to secure the knowledge and evaluation marks on this topic.
