Blackmail, Handling Stolen Goods & Making Off Without Payment: A Level Criminal Law

Quick answer: Blackmail (s21 Theft Act 1968) is making an unwarranted demand with menaces with a view to gain or intent to cause loss. Handling stolen goods (s22) is dishonestly receiving or dealing with goods knowing or believing them to be stolen. Making off without payment (s3 Theft Act 1978) is dishonestly leaving without paying on the spot, intending to avoid payment.

The 2026–2028 Cambridge 9084 syllabus expanded Paper 2 (Criminal Law) to focus on offences against property. Alongside theft, robbery and burglary, criminal damage and fraud, you need to know three shorter offences: blackmail, handling stolen goods and making off without payment.

Blackmail – Section 21 Theft Act 1968

A person is guilty of blackmail if, with a view to gain for himself or another or with intent to cause loss to another, he makes an unwarranted demand with menaces. Maximum sentence: 14 years.

Actus reus

  • Demand – can be express or implied, polite in form, and made by words or conduct (R v Collister and Warhurst (1955)). It is complete when made, e.g. when a letter is posted (Treacy v DPP (1971)).
  • Menaces – threats of any action detrimental to or unpleasant to the person addressed (Thorne v Motor Trade Association (1937)). The threat must be one that would affect an ordinary person of normal stability (R v Clear (1968)), though it can still be menaces if the defendant knows the victim is unusually timid (R v Garwood (1987)).

Mens rea

  • Unwarranted – a demand is unwarranted unless the defendant believes (a) they have reasonable grounds to make it and (b) using menaces is a proper way to reinforce it. Threatening to commit a crime can never be believed to be “proper” (R v Harvey (1981)).
  • With a view to gain or intent to cause loss – gain and loss relate to money or other property, including keeping what one has.

Handling Stolen Goods – Section 22 Theft Act 1968

A person handles stolen goods if (otherwise than in the course of stealing), knowing or believing them to be stolen, he dishonestly receives the goods, or dishonestly undertakes or assists in their retention, removal, disposal or realisation by or for the benefit of another, or arranges to do so. Maximum sentence: 14 years.

Actus reus

  • Stolen goods – includes goods obtained by theft, blackmail or fraud, and their proceeds (s24). Goods stop being stolen once they are restored to lawful possession (Haughton v Smith (1975)).
  • Handling – receiving, or assisting in retention, removal, disposal or realisation. Allowing stolen money to stay in a bank account can be “retention” (R v Pitchley (1972)).
  • “For the benefit of another” – a buyer who purchases goods for himself is not selling for another’s benefit (R v Bloxham (1983)).

Mens rea

  • Knowing or believing the goods are stolen – suspicion alone is not enough (R v Moys (1984)). Belief means the defendant thinks there is no other reasonable explanation (R v Hall (1985)).
  • Dishonesty – judged by the test in Ivey v Genting Casinos (2017), confirmed for criminal law in R v Barton and Booth (2020).

Making Off Without Payment – Section 3 Theft Act 1978

A person who, knowing that payment on the spot for goods supplied or services done is required or expected, dishonestly makes off without having paid as required or expected, with intent to avoid payment, commits an offence. Maximum sentence: 2 years.

Actus reus

  • Payment on the spot is required – e.g. restaurants, petrol stations, taxis.
  • Makes off – leaving the place where payment is due (R v McDavitt (1981), the defendant had not yet left the restaurant). It includes leaving openly or secretly (R v Brooks and Brooks (1982)).
  • Payment must be legally due – in Troughton v Metropolitan Police (1987), a taxi driver broke the contract by not completing the journey, so no payment was legally due.

Mens rea

  • Knowledge that payment on the spot is required.
  • Dishonesty (Ivey test).
  • Intent to avoid payment permanently – R v Allen (1985): a hotel guest who intended to pay later was not guilty.

Quick Comparison

OffenceKey actus reusKey mens reaMax sentence
Blackmail (s21 TA 1968)Demand with menacesUnwarranted; view to gain / intent to cause loss14 years
Handling (s22 TA 1968)Receiving or dealing with stolen goodsKnowing or believing stolen; dishonesty14 years
Making off (s3 TA 1978)Making off without paying on the spotKnowledge; dishonesty; intent to avoid payment permanently2 years

Evaluation Points

  • Blackmail: the subjective “unwarranted” test protects people who genuinely believe their demand is proper, but it can seem too generous to defendants.
  • Handling: the “knowing or believing” requirement excludes people who deliberately avoid asking questions, which can let receivers of stolen goods escape liability.
  • Making off: the Allen requirement of intent to avoid payment permanently makes convictions harder where defendants claim they would pay later.
  • Dishonesty: the Ivey objective test gives consistency but leaves a lot to the jury.

Revise all property offences together using the free Paper 2 criminal law notes and link sentencing questions to our sentencing guide.

Free Past Papers and Notes – Download Now

Lock this topic in by practising real Cambridge questions and revising with our free notes:

→ Download Free A Level Law Past Papers & Mark Schemes
→ Free A Level Law Notes (PDF)
→ Free A Level Law Paper 2 Notes: Criminal Law

Check where this topic sits in the official Cambridge International AS & A Level Law 9084 syllabus.

About Sir Owais Mirchawala’s A Level Law Classes

Sir Owais Mirchawala teaches Cambridge International AS & A Level Law (9084) to students across Pakistan and the Gulf. His AS Level Law course covers Papers 1 and 2 topic by topic through recorded lectures you can study at your own pace, with topical past paper practice, class notes, WhatsApp query support, and homework and mock exam marking. Learn more about Sir Owais Mirchawala, explore the AS Level Law course, read the A Level Law course FAQs, or message him on WhatsApp to enrol.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the elements of blackmail?

An unwarranted demand with menaces, made with a view to gain for oneself or another or with intent to cause loss to another, under section 21 of the Theft Act 1968.

Is suspicion enough for handling stolen goods?

No. The defendant must know or believe the goods are stolen. Suspicion alone is not enough, as held in R v Moys.

What did R v Allen decide about making off without payment?

That the defendant must intend to avoid payment permanently. Intending to pay later is not enough for the offence.

Are blackmail and handling on the 2026 A Level Law syllabus?

Yes. The 2026–2028 Cambridge 9084 syllabus includes blackmail, handling stolen goods and making off without payment in Paper 2 under offences against property.

Final Thought

These three offences are short but precise. Learn the exact statutory wording, one or two cases for each element, and the maximum sentences, and you can pick up quick marks in Paper 2 problem questions.

Scroll to Top

Join A Level Law Classes with Sir Owais Mirchawala

Leave your details and our team will contact you about AS & A2 Level Law classes.